Breaking Founder Dependency with Peter Boolkah
Peter Boolkah has spent 21 years and over 60,000 hours coaching founders, and he identifies one pattern that stalls scaleups: leadership teams that exist by name, not by behaviour. In this episode of Built by People Leaders, Peter Boolkah — award-winning business coach, author of Your Business Sucks, and creator of The Hamster Wheel Trap® framework — unpacks how founder dependency forms in the earliest days of a company and why most leadership teams remain stuck in execution mode even as headcount scales past 100. His 15 years at McDonald's taught him systemization and leadership training at scale, but also revealed a costly mistake: promoting managers too quickly out of loyalty, placing them in roles they couldn't perform, and effectively ending their careers.

For People leaders at companies in the 100–1,500 employee range, Peter Boolkah's episode addresses the structural breaking point most scaleups hit: when informal communication breaks down, the leadership team can no longer oversee everything directly, and managers promoted "by total, not by training" remain zoomed into execution work instead of strategy. Peter Boolkah explains why approximately 80% of startups fail before year five, how the player-manager trap keeps teams from building strategic capacity, and what HR leaders must do to shift from being perceived as the "red tape department" to becoming the business enabler that helps founders scale through people.
Challenges Addressed
  • Founder Dependency and The Hamster Wheel Trap®: Peter Boolkah explains that solopreneurs and early-stage founders train their businesses to be reliant on them — a habit formed in the startup phase that becomes nearly impossible to break as companies scale. The Hamster Wheel Trap® framework helps business owners recognize when their presence has become the bottleneck and how to build leadership capacity that doesn't depend on the founder making every decision.
  • Leadership Teams That Exist by Name, Not by Behaviour: Peter Boolkah identifies a pattern across scaleups: managers promoted by loyalty rather than training continue doing execution work instead of strategic work, and when the business outgrows the competency of its leadership team, the organisation implodes. These "leadership teams by name, not by behaviour" lack the business knowledge and strategic thinking required to operate at the executive level, leaving founders overwhelmed and the company stuck.
  • HR as Business Enabler vs. Red Tape Department: Peter Boolkah argues that HR professionals must position themselves as business enablers who help founders scale through people, not as compliance officers who only protect employees. For People leaders at scaleups, this means helping founders hire the right people, implement proper performance management systems, and build the confidence to discipline or exit employees when necessary — skills most business owners never learn on their own.
Actionable Takeaways
  1. Conduct a proper team appraisal before investing in leadership development programs. Peter Boolkah emphasizes that not everyone has strategic thinking capability, and just because someone is a great manager doesn't mean they should be promoted to an executive role. Assess whether your current leadership team can be developed for strategic work and whether executives genuinely want to grow — many see promotion as a destination rather than a process and will resist the learning required to operate at the next level.
  2. Require managers to backfill their previous roles before promoting them to executive positions. Peter Boolkah describes the player-manager problem: when managers remain zoomed into execution work, they cannot zoom out to strategy. If a newly promoted executive still holds operational responsibilities, they become ineffective in both roles. People leaders should build a promotion process that ensures management capacity exists below the executive team before elevating anyone.
  3. Use skills and capability gap analysis to build the business case for people investment. As Peter Boolkah notes, founders often don't know what they don't know, and most only make change when they're in pain. People leaders should conduct a structured evaluation of what capabilities already exist in the organisation and what's missing, then present that gap analysis to the CEO or founder to demonstrate why people investment, training, and leadership development are necessary to scale the business.
Questions This Episode Answers
  • How do I know if my leadership team is ready for strategic work or if they're still operating as managers? Peter Boolkah explains that most leadership teams in scaleups are "by name, not by behaviour" — they've been promoted by loyalty rather than training and remain stuck doing execution work instead of strategic planning. Assess whether your executives are still zoomed into day-to-day tasks (the player-manager problem) or whether they've backfilled their previous roles and developed the business knowledge required to think strategically. If the business is outgrowing the competency of its leadership team, the organisation will implode.

  • What's the best way to make the case to a founder that we need to invest in leadership development? Peter Boolkah recommends conducting a proper team appraisal and capability gap analysis first. Identify what skills and strategic capacity your organisation currently has and what's missing, then present that analysis to the founder to show where the business is stuck. Most founders only make change when they're in pain, so People leaders must help them see the specific capabilities the company lacks and how people investment will enable the business to scale.

  • How should we promote managers to executive roles without repeating the mistakes Peter Boolkah saw at McDonald's? Peter Boolkah describes how McDonald's promoted people too quickly out of loyalty and ruined careers by placing managers in roles they couldn't perform. To avoid this, People leaders should assess whether a manager has the strategic thinking capability and genuine desire to grow before promotion, ensure they backfill their previous role so they're not stuck as player-managers, and provide the training and business knowledge required to operate at the executive level rather than assuming they'll figure it out on their own.
Links & Resources Mentioned:
Daria Rudnik (00:05.93)
Welcome to Built by People Leaders Podcast. I'm your host, Daria Rudnik, and this show is for HR and L&D leaders, those building real impact from within and shaping AI ready organizations. Each episode, I sit down with people leaders to talk about how they build strong cultures and shape organizations around them. It's about HR being seen as a true business partner by leaders and by HR themselves. So let's dive in because today I have a very special guest, Peter Boolkah

Who's an award-winning business coach, entrepreneur, author, and keynote speaker, who has spent more than two decades helping founders build businesses that can thrive without them. He's the author of Your Business Sucks and the creator of the Hamster Build Trap, a framework that helps business owners overcome founder dependency, develop stronger leaders and teams, and build a business that creates freedom rather than consuming their lives. Welcome, Peter.

Peter Boolkah (01:03.119)
Thank you, Daria. What a beautiful introduction. I'm so happy to be here today.

Daria Rudnik (01:08.162)
I'm so happy to have you. I have so many questions for you because you're so right. The world is changing so fast. There's so many things happening. How do business leaders, HR leaders, how can they survive in that?

Peter Boolkah (01:25.531)
They need to be relevant to the world in which we are living. They need to they need to evolve their relevancy. And the world is crazy. I mean, we look at it, the last six years have been mad. I mean, you've had COVID, supply chain crisis, global inflation, Ukraine war, Iranian war, Palestine, Israeli conflict. And you're now seeing the biggest change in how we interact with data in our lifetime. I mean, AI.

It's totally rewriting the playing field as we know it.

Daria Rudnik (02:00.693)
Yeah, that's so true. And we'll dive into that. But before we go there, tell us a little bit about yourself and your journey.

Peter Boolkah (02:08.929)
My journey has probably been semi conventional. I did there school, college, university while working full time in McDonald's. I actually did 15 years with McDonald's, so it was a very interesting journey in terms of learning business, systemization process, and these and management training, leadership training, things I took for granted when I was working there. Then I left the corporate world, bought a restaurant because I liked cooking.

Realised that cooking for a hundred and fifty people a night was shit, sold a restaurant, and I ended up being as a business coach. And it wasn't something that I necessarily chose to do. Sometimes things happened for a reason and I fell into it. And twenty one years later, I am still here.

Daria Rudnik (02:54.765)
Well, you mentioned learn business and we talk a lot about HR leaders that they need to understand business, they need to learn business. But what does it mean?

Peter Boolkah (03:09.381)
I think you need to understand the people you're working with. And actually, especially for HR professionals, I mean they've got a quite a varied, probably customer base. They'll deal with corporates, but the biggest marketplace clearly are SMEs around the world. And actually a corporate avatar and an SME avatar, depending on what's what where they are in their journey, are very different.

And I think it's understanding what the business owner, what the founder wants to achieve for a from a HR partner and how it will help them build their business. A lot of people see HR as being the people that stop businesses from growing. It's like the red tape department. When actually HR done right is far from the red tape department. It's an enabler for an organization to grow. But I think in some organizations,

It's gone too far the other way, where it's all about protecting the employee, not protecting the organization. Whereas when you're a founder and you don't have the biggest resource pool in the world, you need a HR professional on board that's going to protect the organization and be on the side of the founder, not necessarily on the side of the employee.

Daria Rudnik (04:26.636)
Yeah. Well, what I see I kind of two parts, two edges. Like one is HR is on the side of the employees saying they need training, they need engagement, they need motivation, they need well being, they need a ping pong table table, but like not thinking about business. But on the other side there is this compliance and w we need to like

there are certain rules that you need to follow those rules and we cannot we need to protect the company if b by following those rules and it's all about kind of compliance and business and not about people and kind of tr and and both are important. I mean you need to be all of it and and still helping businesses grow.

Peter Boolkah (05:05.339)
Yep.

Daria Rudnik (05:14.036)
What is the most like you've you've worked with business owners and founders and executives. What do they need the most from a partner who helps their business grow? How to become that kind of partner? that to help them grow business organizations?

Peter Boolkah (05:17.69)
Yep.

Peter Boolkah (05:29.295)
You know what? It depends on where they it depends on where they are in their business growth. But very often it's gonna be the confidence to be able to perhaps how to hire the right people. Systems in place for our proper performance management.

When you have a problem with employees, I mean this sounds really simple, I know, but how to discipline having systems in place to discipline people. And unfortunately at times we're gonna have to exit people. How to exit people from the organisation.

And things like that are so so simple. Yeah, these are things that business owners don't learn on their own. And because they don't have those skills, too often either employees get away with murder, metaphorically speaking, of course, and they never get sacked because the business owner is too afraid, doesn't have the confidence to do what's right for the business.

And I've seen too many business owners be bullied by their employees.

Which I know you sound surpr you seem surprised by that, but it is true. True story.

Daria Rudnik (06:50.018)
That's crazy. I also I I always thought of kind of business owners as more direct people because otherwise how can you founders at least how can you build a business if you're not like direct and straight to the point and get what you need? And now I'm hearing something there is something else there.

Peter Boolkah (07:09.307)
Yeah, but you come in, look when we're in corporate, we get taught a set of skills. We get taught to how to do these things. So actually, it becomes normal for us. But for business owners, very often many of them don't even finish school, as an example. So quite a lot of the people I've worked with are dyslexic, ADHD, autistic. The education system wasn't right for them.

They went, they had an idea, they had nothing to lose, so they went and worked for themselves. Which is which is good. But the flip side of that is there are so many things that you need in business that they never learn.

There was so much missing. And actually, you know the challenge is most business owners they don't they don't study. Because they had an unpleasant experience either at school or maybe they did their studies, they did a their school, college, university, got education fatigue and said, I don't want to learn anymore, I just want to do not realising that when you start a business, you are and most businesses that start up are solo printers anyway.

They start by themselves. So when you start a business, you're head of sales, head of marketing, head of HR, in case you need to discipline yourself, head of finance, head of operations, head of whatever it is. You're you you are everything. But they've never learned sales, marketing, HR. So they're just going with an idea and thinking that w hard work alone will be enough to succeed. And you know the interesting thing is, it's not. Today,

There's approximately eleven thousand hours. I mean eleven thousand businesses that start up every single hour. Eleven thousand. Now of which eighty percent of them will fail before we get to year five. Can you believe that? Eighty percent failure rate. That's unbelievable.

Daria Rudnik (09:15.478)
Yeah, yeah, we we saw that statistics, I know. It's it's hard. It's hard. It is very hard. And you're right. I mean, businesses to grow they need teams, teams with certain expertise, with certain knowledge and certain experience. marketing, finance. But again, building starting business on your own, growing the business on their own, it's pretty hard to give up the decision making process.

Peter Boolkah (09:19.555)
It's shocking. Yeah.

Daria Rudnik (09:45.708)
So yeah, how do you how do you help leaders do that?

Peter Boolkah (09:45.989)
Cheer.

Peter Boolkah (09:51.803)
Problem is if you're a solopreneur, unless you have external people working for you, contractors, you are never going to be able to give up the decision making because it's only you. And you think about the early days in business, you form habits. And one of the greatest habits that business owners form, if they're by themselves, because they're the only decision maker, they train the business to be reliant on them.

And that's a habit that's hard to break. And sometimes I always say to business owners, the person that got you to where you are here today will not be the person that gets you to where you need to be.

Peter Boolkah (10:33.859)
And you they're gonna have to learn some new skills and change in order to be able to take the business to the next level.

Daria Rudnik (10:42.041)
Well, same goes to like the executive team. When someone joins a company, okay, as a startup team and they grow and they scale. They need to change too. How do you know how do you know when to change and how to change? Because you don't have like you the all the reality and all the experience you have as a startup like business founder. And when something is changing, how do you know it's time to change?

Peter Boolkah (10:53.946)
One hundred percent.

Peter Boolkah (11:09.295)
Well, normally what you'll find is the executive team isn't the executive team. They're just the management team or the supervisor team. They have been promoted by total, not by training. So they don't have the behaviours of executives anyway. They're not doing any of the strategic work the executives would be doing. They're still dealing with the execution work that they were once doing.

So actually it's about getting the structure in the organization right. There's no point having an exec team if you don't have the management team below them that's fully trained to do the management so the executive team can do the exec stuff.

Daria Rudnik (11:48.985)
Can you do both?

Peter Boolkah (11:51.663)
Well, okay, so I like my sport and in the UK I'm a big fan of football. When you're a player manager and you're on the pitch, you have a very restricted viewpoint. So it's quite difficult to be able to when you're caught up in the day to day, it's quite difficult to zoom out when you're zoomed in.

So I do that's one of the biggest problems. That's why when they promote managers, people get promoted to managers because they're very good at their jobs. But what the managers never do is backfill their positions when they get promoted to the exec team. And it's not ideal doing both, because then they never get to a point where they deliver where they necessarily develop the managers or the future, and they remain in two roles.

And then become quite ineffective in both.

Daria Rudnik (12:51.225)
Well that is actually really interesting conversation because I mean I'm thinking about the structures and layers a lot. And I I believe that it's it's very hard to define how many managerial levels we need to have in the organization. And by having in a smaller company, by having executive team and management team, we kind of have too many managers in one place. So how do you s how do you solve that in a small?

Peter Boolkah (13:16.091)
I agree with that.

Peter Boolkah (13:21.029)
Just have a management team. Just have a management team. Because well, at the end of the day, if it's a smaller team and you've got managers, most of the most of the strategy is going to come from the from the founder. Because actually the managers haven't had enough of a development to be able to think strategically.

Daria Rudnik (13:21.249)
Not so big company. But who will think about the strategy? Like, what about the strategy?

Peter Boolkah (13:44.741)
When you get to exec level, there's gonna be a lot of training and development you would have had to be able to think d d on that level. Most managers they don't have the ability to think at that level.

Daria Rudnik (13:57.934)
When you say training and development, do you mean like formal training?

Peter Boolkah (14:01.571)
A mixture of both. Mixture of both, mixture of everything. I mean to to be able to be a great strategist, you're gonna have to have a lot of business knowledge on you to be able to know what to strategize. Having an idea is not strategy. It's just having an opinion. Every arsehole on the planet has an opinion. It doesn't mean that's gonna grow the business.

Daria Rudnik (14:24.611)
I've seen a lot of business owners with no formal training and well, I would call them leadership teams with no formal training growing their companies, making decisions. Are we assuming they're not doing their job right or what?

Peter Boolkah (14:29.947)
Mm.

Peter Boolkah (14:44.197)
There'll be the occasional one that does it really good.

But when you look at the majority, the majority of businesses at scale, the leadership and management team are in chaos.

Because the business outgrows their competency.

And they haven't got a clue how to get the business under control.

Daria Rudnik (15:09.539)
That's recognizable.

Peter Boolkah (15:11.639)
Yeah, and that's what we call implosion. And then by that time, that's why I say that very often, you'll have a leadership team by name, not by behaviour.

Daria Rudnik (15:14.047)
Okay.

Daria Rudnik (15:26.969)
Well, let's say we have an HR leader joining a company. And I I've had those kind of conversations when they say we need leadership training, we need to develop and grow our leaders. We need to help them be more strategic. We need to be help them lead their teams and not just give like tasks and control those tasks. It's more than that. What's the best way to show the founder

Peter Boolkah (15:32.133)
Mm-hmm.

Daria Rudnik (15:56.495)
see or that it's time to train and and change.

Peter Boolkah (16:03.045)
I think first you need to have a proper appraisal of the team. Because not everybody is going to be strategic in their thinking. Not everybody's got that skill set. And just because someone is a great manager, sometimes a great manager needs to remain a great manager. And that was one of the things at McDonald's. We promoted people very quickly and very often we ruined people's careers because we promoted them into a position they could never do.

We thought, okay, because we were being loyal to them and we thought we were rewarding them, let's promote that person. That was the worst thing we could do. We finished their career off.

Peter Boolkah (16:47.119)
So I think you need to assess the team and ask yourself the question, is this a team that we can develop? Is it the right team to develop? But the other question's gotta be, do the executives want to be developed? 'Cause I've seen a lot of people get promoted and they think that that's it, that's their journey done.

I'm now in the executive team. I have arrived. They see it as being a destination. Not realising that actually the company is moving.

And actually if they're stuck at the stop, they're just gonna be watching the company go into the distance without them. So I think there's a lot of things. And I've sorry.

Daria Rudnik (17:30.756)
Yeah. Well it's a

Peter Boolkah (17:36.207)
No no one thing I was going to say is like everybody loves the romance about being I'm an executive but they're not necessarily prepared for the sacrifice and hard work needed to execute that.

Daria Rudnik (17:52.793)
Yeah. I mean you're right. Being executive at five hundred people company, fifteen hundred people company and thousands of employees, hundreds of thousands of employees, a totally different story. So definitely it's not the the destination, it's a process and it's a huge learning opportunity.

Tell us about your book.

Peter Boolkah (18:19.417)
Your business sucks. Yeah. Look, what it is, the book actually itself is a twenty-year research project into companies. So I spent the last twenty-one years into businesses, over sixty thousand hours w with founders. it's interesting, over the twenty-year period, certain things just come up and up and up. And

The companies that succeed, they succeed for certain reasons. The companies that fail consistently, they also fail for certain reasons. So I wanted your business acts to become the introduction to actually why things happen in business. But more importantly, if founders, CEOs want to change their trajectory, perhaps where they need to focus their efforts to take the business to where they want it to be. Because the reality is if you're starting your own business, business

Peter Boolkah (19:21.637)
Yeah, I've seen too many business owners where the business hasn't made their life better. It's actually destroyed their life, which is so sad.

Daria Rudnik (19:32.995)
Yeah, it is.

And still like how do you recognize the moment when instead of h making your life better, it makes your life worse and then business like you need to grow, you need to change or hire a team. Are there any milestones or signals that business owners can look into and understand, okay, it's time to change, it's time to do something.

Peter Boolkah (20:02.171)
Well, number okay, so God's biggest feedback mechanism loop is pain. So mo most people make change when they're in pain. So they can't cope with the stress or anymore that they're they're absolutely miserable. And that's a bit of a shame because that becomes a little bit too long. That's a bit too late in the day. You really want to make it beforehand. But most people make that mis make that change once they're stuck and they realize that they're no longer moving forward.

Now some entrepreneurs will never make that change. So if you look at the UK, we have approximately five point it's about five point seven million small to medium sized privately owned businesses, of which four point three million are solopreneurs, which means they're never ever going to get away from that. The business will always be them. And they will always have a job, not a business. And that's choice.

Well, for the others, they've just got to decide, okay, where they're going to take the business and what needs to happen for the business to get there. And I don't think there's a single point that says, Okay, a founder dis makes that decision. Normally is when they become tired and don't know what to do next. Which is crazy.

Daria Rudnik (21:20.612)
You make it so sad. What's what's the being of light there? What how people can change that and actually

Peter Boolkah (21:29.243)
They have to change them. This is the thing. They have to change them. You can only do what you know. Right? You only can do what you know. So when your business is stuck, I love the saying that God created man in his image. And if that is to be true, then every founder has created their business in their image, the good, the bad, and the ugly. And I don't know if they want their business to change, they have to be the change. They have to change first. You

Like I said just a minute ago, you can't do what you don't know. So you need to start learning.

Daria Rudnik (22:04.292)
Yeah, well I I do agree that learning is a is a is important. and

Peter Boolkah (22:09.883)
Critical. Critical today.

Daria Rudnik (22:11.746)
And unfortunately a lot of like again business leaders owners say we don't have time and they don't have that time because of the all the things you mentioned before, with all the change happening in the world, with AI race, when companies just understand we need to move faster, deliver more, be be faster than anyone else, and they don't have t time to learn.

Peter Boolkah (22:36.185)
And that's fine. And you know what I say to them? Enjoy repeating next year the same as you did this year. Because you're just putting your business into photocopier mode. You'll just pass another year. You'll be no further forward, but you survived another year, well done. But then what will happen when your competition's doing the learning? At some point they will outlearn you, and then you're screwed.

Daria Rudnik (23:09.626)
Well, Peter, that's really an interesting conversation about the challenges businesses face now. What would be your advice to HR leaders on how to help the leaders learn and start to change?

Peter Boolkah (23:28.315)
I think looking at where they're stuck, and more importantly, when you come with your skill set, how does your how can your skill set help the founder get control and scale? Because you can't scale without people. That's why I say the HR function is really important.

Daria Rudnik (23:47.866)
Mm-hmm.

Peter Boolkah (23:48.889)
You cannot scale without people. But it's helping the founder learn how to scale through people.

Daria Rudnik (23:56.635)
Well, thanks for this conversation. So from what I hear, HR, I mean, you cannot scale without people, obviously. And and you need to develop and grow those people. And if you hear some complaints or kind of risk like a resistance towards learning, just do a proper performance management and evaluation. What kind of skills you already have and capabilities you have in the organizations and what is it that you don't have?

And show that to your CEO and founder and so that they see, yes, there is this need to change and grow because we don't have skills we need to grow and and and scale. I repeat myself twice. But anyway, how people can learn more about you? How people can reach out to you and how can they find your book?

Peter Boolkah (24:41.645)
the book's really easy. Just go to Amazon, type in your business sucks, and it comes straight up. And it's available on Hardback, Paperback, Kindle for 99 cents in the US. And it's also available on Audible. So you've got all the met the modalities of learning covered. And the other thing is look if you want to reach out to me, connect, follow, just type my name into Google. You'll find my website, my podcast channel, my YouTube channel, my LinkedIn,

Twitter or my X, should I say, Instagram, Facebook. Choose your poison. It's up to you how you connect.

Daria Rudnik (25:17.456)
We have most of the links in the notes to this episode. So please click, follow Peter, get the book, and and grow your business. And to those who listen to us till the end, thank you so much. If you like this episode, please give us five stars on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Subscribe to our YouTube channel and stay tuned for the next episodes. Bye.

Peter Boolkah (25:42.821)
Thank you for having me.